I work in research on the biostatistics side. I thought scientists would be excited at getting closer at the truth. It is hard admitting being wrong and spending years in error, but it’s harder to continue living a lie and attempting to warp reality to conform to it. This assuming vox day is correct and I think he is. Especially the use of AI to rigorously test and compare his theories to scientific papers on the topic. Merci beaucoup Claude Athos!
“I didn’t read the book and won’t because I have a BS in BS and I just know Vox Day’s book is BS because someone on the internet says he’s a bad man and shouldn’t be paid attention to, so obviously anything he says is wrong. Whatever it is.”
Carry on, people. Don’t mind me, I’m just getting another bucket of popcorn.
The insecure rush to save their house of cards from collapsing.
The pseudoscientific and panic driven response tells you a lot about the nature of the evidence for evolution. Namely that the perception of it as “overwhelming” is just a masquerade protected by bluster and false confidence more than anything.
Day has effectively shown that Haldane’s dilemma (the nature of the problem he deals with) really is fatal to Darwinian evolution.
It's really funny to hear the critics haven't read the book, and have no idea what the actual arguments are. Is this really the best they've got? I mean, come on! It's about a three hour read!
DNA is the best argument. The fact is that, of yeast's 6,000 genes, roughly 2,000–2,300 have ortholog groups in mammals. If we compare human DNA to that of apes and monkeys, the similarities are above 90%.
It looks like I can get this book for free from Kindle Unlimited, so maybe I will.
Edit: I did read some of it. It seems to rely on some “maximum rate of adoption of a favorable mutation” to “prove” that natural selection couldn’t happen fast enough The argument devolves into some complicated genetic questions which I won’t try to address, but let’s summarize:
The “intelligent design” people are reduced to arguing that God was in there pushing the right mutations, because otherwise they couldn’t have occurred randomly in time.
Oh please. For each of the billions of species, He guided the process along to output them, rather than just creating the species in one fell swoop?
This article reminds me of the "Republicans pounce" theme of mainstream news: to them, the news is not that something happened -- it's that those BAD people are using it.
If the fastest human being can sprint 100m in 9 seconds, that mathematically proves that a rate that requires 1 km in 10 seconds is outside human ability. That's one order of magnitude.
Evolution has a shortfall of 6 orders of magnitude. The fixation rate is too low for the amount of evolutionary progress needed. Do you believe Usain Bolt can sprint 100,000 kilometers in 9 seconds?
If you don't, you are capable of understanding mathematical impossibility.
In any case, I have a B.S. in Math and I understand probability quite well. Also worked in Google Ads Quality, which is all about statistics. I’ll match my credentials against Day’s anytime.
Your premises are wrong, so the relevant phrase here is “garbage in, garbage out.”
“Fixation rate” is just the ID’ers’ latest dodge. Before that, it was “vision and the eye could not have evolved in steps” which was convincingly refuted. So now you’re on to ignoring neutral drift, recombination, and parallel fixation. Once that one’s been put to bed, you’ll have something else.
As for reading the whole book: YOU read “Why Evolution is True” (Jerry Coyne) and then we can talk.
Of course I did not mean to say that, that'd be stupid.
Someone who believes Usain bolt can sprint 100,000 kilometers in 9 seconds is mathematically-challenged and incompetent to check their beliefs against reality.
Your inability to process my simple comment bodes ill for your ability to comprehend Vox's book in a quick skim, mathematical degree or not.
Fixation rate is not a dodge. It mathematically follows the claim that evolution generated the genetic diversity of biological life. So what are the measurable numbers? What are the average rates?
It'd be like asking you how many people clicked on an ad to generate $10,000 in revenue. Objective reality generates quantifiable numbers.
Fixation rate is, almost by definition, unmeasurable; especially when we’re talking hundreds of millions ago. As my “your ability to comprehend Vox's book” you’re about one Reply from getting Blocked. I don’t waste time on trash-talking losers.
I haven’t read this, but I think the excellent book Laws of the Game by Eigen and Winkler might deal with the mathematical argument. TL;DR: the combination of random chance constrained by physical laws rapidly produces remarkable complexity.
Beyond that, there’s a basic problem with Day’s argument. To say “Life/Earth/the universe is too complex, therefore it must have been created by God” just pushes the problem up one level. Isn’t God at least as complex as the universe He created? So, who created Him? If the response is “Nobody, He just exists,” then why can’t the universe just exist?
I’m just trying to have a polite discussion about a general topic I’m somewhat familiar with. I’m perfectly willing to give your specific argument a fair shake. Have you read Eigen and Winkler?
If evolution (or some portion of it) is “impossible,” then what is the explanation? All the ones I’ve seen involve God or something God-like (simulation theory), which just seems to push the question to another level.
The irony in all of this being the average biologist still doesn’t know what the term average means.
I work in research on the biostatistics side. I thought scientists would be excited at getting closer at the truth. It is hard admitting being wrong and spending years in error, but it’s harder to continue living a lie and attempting to warp reality to conform to it. This assuming vox day is correct and I think he is. Especially the use of AI to rigorously test and compare his theories to scientific papers on the topic. Merci beaucoup Claude Athos!
The great thing about admitting you were wrong is that afterwards, you get to be right.
“I didn’t read the book and won’t because I have a BS in BS and I just know Vox Day’s book is BS because someone on the internet says he’s a bad man and shouldn’t be paid attention to, so obviously anything he says is wrong. Whatever it is.”
Carry on, people. Don’t mind me, I’m just getting another bucket of popcorn.
The insecure rush to save their house of cards from collapsing.
The pseudoscientific and panic driven response tells you a lot about the nature of the evidence for evolution. Namely that the perception of it as “overwhelming” is just a masquerade protected by bluster and false confidence more than anything.
Day has effectively shown that Haldane’s dilemma (the nature of the problem he deals with) really is fatal to Darwinian evolution.
It's really funny to hear the critics haven't read the book, and have no idea what the actual arguments are. Is this really the best they've got? I mean, come on! It's about a three hour read!
DNA is the best argument. The fact is that, of yeast's 6,000 genes, roughly 2,000–2,300 have ortholog groups in mammals. If we compare human DNA to that of apes and monkeys, the similarities are above 90%.
It looks like I can get this book for free from Kindle Unlimited, so maybe I will.
Edit: I did read some of it. It seems to rely on some “maximum rate of adoption of a favorable mutation” to “prove” that natural selection couldn’t happen fast enough The argument devolves into some complicated genetic questions which I won’t try to address, but let’s summarize:
The “intelligent design” people are reduced to arguing that God was in there pushing the right mutations, because otherwise they couldn’t have occurred randomly in time.
Oh please. For each of the billions of species, He guided the process along to output them, rather than just creating the species in one fell swoop?
This article reminds me of the "Republicans pounce" theme of mainstream news: to them, the news is not that something happened -- it's that those BAD people are using it.
"it seems"
You didn't finish the book.
If the fastest human being can sprint 100m in 9 seconds, that mathematically proves that a rate that requires 1 km in 10 seconds is outside human ability. That's one order of magnitude.
Evolution has a shortfall of 6 orders of magnitude. The fixation rate is too low for the amount of evolutionary progress needed. Do you believe Usain Bolt can sprint 100,000 kilometers in 9 seconds?
If you don't, you are capable of understanding mathematical impossibility.
I think you meant to say,
“If you don't, you are NOT capable”
In any case, I have a B.S. in Math and I understand probability quite well. Also worked in Google Ads Quality, which is all about statistics. I’ll match my credentials against Day’s anytime.
Your premises are wrong, so the relevant phrase here is “garbage in, garbage out.”
“Fixation rate” is just the ID’ers’ latest dodge. Before that, it was “vision and the eye could not have evolved in steps” which was convincingly refuted. So now you’re on to ignoring neutral drift, recombination, and parallel fixation. Once that one’s been put to bed, you’ll have something else.
As for reading the whole book: YOU read “Why Evolution is True” (Jerry Coyne) and then we can talk.
Of course I did not mean to say that, that'd be stupid.
Someone who believes Usain bolt can sprint 100,000 kilometers in 9 seconds is mathematically-challenged and incompetent to check their beliefs against reality.
Your inability to process my simple comment bodes ill for your ability to comprehend Vox's book in a quick skim, mathematical degree or not.
Fixation rate is not a dodge. It mathematically follows the claim that evolution generated the genetic diversity of biological life. So what are the measurable numbers? What are the average rates?
It'd be like asking you how many people clicked on an ad to generate $10,000 in revenue. Objective reality generates quantifiable numbers.
Fixation rate is, almost by definition, unmeasurable; especially when we’re talking hundreds of millions ago. As my “your ability to comprehend Vox's book” you’re about one Reply from getting Blocked. I don’t waste time on trash-talking losers.
That's where epigenetics and sexual selection come in
And fail to do the job as well.
Nobody is scambling over this junk science.
I’d be interested to hear Bret Weinstein’s/Heather Heying’s take.
Can you believe this man like in his 60s? To look this good at that age is real top tier genetics.
I haven’t read this, but I think the excellent book Laws of the Game by Eigen and Winkler might deal with the mathematical argument. TL;DR: the combination of random chance constrained by physical laws rapidly produces remarkable complexity.
Beyond that, there’s a basic problem with Day’s argument. To say “Life/Earth/the universe is too complex, therefore it must have been created by God” just pushes the problem up one level. Isn’t God at least as complex as the universe He created? So, who created Him? If the response is “Nobody, He just exists,” then why can’t the universe just exist?
You are too stupid to converse with. You fail to read a book, imagine what it says, then create a lame argument to flog and nearly fail at that.
I’ve read many pro- and anti-evolution arguments, so I’m familiar with many of the arguments.
I learned algebra in school, so I am familiar with many of the details of differential calculus as applied to fluid flow.
I've read many books, so I am a library.
My dog was born in a barn, so that makes her a cow.
Wtf!
“I haven’t read the book”
Opinion discarded
It doesn't.
And there isn't, because that has nothing to do with my argument.
If you don't want to look stupid, never talk about a book you haven't read.
I’m just trying to have a polite discussion about a general topic I’m somewhat familiar with. I’m perfectly willing to give your specific argument a fair shake. Have you read Eigen and Winkler?
If evolution (or some portion of it) is “impossible,” then what is the explanation? All the ones I’ve seen involve God or something God-like (simulation theory), which just seems to push the question to another level.