Dune: Part Three changes the central relationship in Frank Herbert’s Dune Messiah, and six weeks before release the cast is already defending the decision, showing there might be problems for the marketing of the film.
To be fair, as Hollywood adaptations of sf go, the first two seem pretty good. But there is an old writers quip about editors: some people don’t like the flavor of a story until they piss into it.
Very few good creative works can be directly transferred from one media to another without transforming it to some degree - and a great deal of license should be extended to those who adapt such works.
That said, there’s a huge difference between creative license and subversion.
Take just about any film/series adaptation of Le Comte de Monte-Cristo - acting, direction, and production value are at a level deserving of Dumas (the same cannot be said for Three Musketeers adaptations). It’s a long book, and abridging the story by combining/omitting characters or simplifying the plot is likely necessary to keep the attention of a modern audience.
Still, every single adaptation I’ve ever seen loses me at the very end, when it either reunites Mercedes and Dantès or has Haydée actually fall in love with Albert.
They’ve never left me feeling anything but betrayed by the time the credits roll.
“He saw ‘a strong opportunity there to create a character…’” I’m going to stop you right there, Denis. If I want a character created by you, I’ll go see an original film you wrote. When I go see an adaptation of Frank Herbert’s “Dune,” I want a character created by Frank Herbert.
"Villeneuve frames the film as personal. He told Empire: 'It’s a movie that is talking about something that is very human, which is the idea of a separation, the idea of a divorce.'"
Even the "good" directors can't help themselves. They just have to stick their d--- in the peanut butter.
Nobody but Denis Villeneuve cares about Denis Villeneuve's divorce. if you can't make a multi hundred million dollar film trilogy based on one of the most beloved and respected sci-fi properties of all time and not MAKE IT ALL ABOUT YOU, then don't make it at all.
Only problem is, no one's buying tickets to "Denis Villeneuve's Divorce: The Denis Villeneuve Divorce Story."
Musicians (like Sting, in his songs Every Breath You Take, and King Of Pain) can do that. Sometimes, writers (like in Taxi Driver) can do it. Directors can’t.
I’m pretty happy with the visuals, the world and the performances. I’m sure it’ll be fine. I can live with thematic departures. At least the cannon was mostly completed - Looking at you Mr RR Martin.
As Dune progresses, I see Paul becoming ever more the reluctant hero, doing what he must but trapped within it. And the three women - Alia, Chani and Irulan - all join him in his fate.
Dune Messiah is Paul trying - and mostly failing - to process his sense of guilt for what has been done from his actions and in his name. And in some sense abandons his friends and loved ones in the process.
This is in contrast to Leto and his sister, who embrace fate rather than trying to circumvent it. Like his father, Leto does not let power go to his head. Unlike his father, he lets it into his heart and both he and the universe are better for it.
I don't mind them taking creative liberties with the original story, as long as it results in a good film. Humans are allowed to rewrite & adapt stories. That's what keeps it interesting. I thought the first two films were OK-good, not great, but not bad either, so maybe them deviating from the novel(s) on the third one could be a good sign.
This is a retarded choice if they want to keep making money off the series. The characters later in the series are absolutely defined by what happened to the family. Also, who wants to watch another lame divorce trope movie? I could see why they might make Chani more of a main character while working in the political scene - the stupid way would be to make her like the Lannister woman from GoT, but I could easily see them doing it.
So instead of telling Herbets story the Director gives us a narcissistic meditation on his own divorce. I saw the other two. But I am not even tempted.
Pretty obvious they had to give her more agency to conform to rules against 'passive women' these days.
I wasn't expecting an un-woke Dune, but if it had been made after the Democrats retook power if would have been even worse. It's only downhill from here!
Why can’t they simply make they own story from scratch, instead of telling us “here is Dune, but it’s not a real Dune”?
To be fair, as Hollywood adaptations of sf go, the first two seem pretty good. But there is an old writers quip about editors: some people don’t like the flavor of a story until they piss into it.
Very few good creative works can be directly transferred from one media to another without transforming it to some degree - and a great deal of license should be extended to those who adapt such works.
That said, there’s a huge difference between creative license and subversion.
Take just about any film/series adaptation of Le Comte de Monte-Cristo - acting, direction, and production value are at a level deserving of Dumas (the same cannot be said for Three Musketeers adaptations). It’s a long book, and abridging the story by combining/omitting characters or simplifying the plot is likely necessary to keep the attention of a modern audience.
Still, every single adaptation I’ve ever seen loses me at the very end, when it either reunites Mercedes and Dantès or has Haydée actually fall in love with Albert.
They’ve never left me feeling anything but betrayed by the time the credits roll.
“That said, there’s a huge difference between creative license and subversion.”
A thousand times this.
Funnily, Gankutsuou, the anime adaption, AFAIK does neither. But it takes even more liberties in other ways, so YMMV.
I started watching it a few weeks ago. It’s definitely a unique take (and I’m willing to extend a little more leeway to anime than to live action)….
At the time, I wanted something a bit more faithful to the original, but I’ll revisit it, someday.
“He saw ‘a strong opportunity there to create a character…’” I’m going to stop you right there, Denis. If I want a character created by you, I’ll go see an original film you wrote. When I go see an adaptation of Frank Herbert’s “Dune,” I want a character created by Frank Herbert.
"Villeneuve frames the film as personal. He told Empire: 'It’s a movie that is talking about something that is very human, which is the idea of a separation, the idea of a divorce.'"
Even the "good" directors can't help themselves. They just have to stick their d--- in the peanut butter.
Nobody but Denis Villeneuve cares about Denis Villeneuve's divorce. if you can't make a multi hundred million dollar film trilogy based on one of the most beloved and respected sci-fi properties of all time and not MAKE IT ALL ABOUT YOU, then don't make it at all.
Only problem is, no one's buying tickets to "Denis Villeneuve's Divorce: The Denis Villeneuve Divorce Story."
Musicians (like Sting, in his songs Every Breath You Take, and King Of Pain) can do that. Sometimes, writers (like in Taxi Driver) can do it. Directors can’t.
I genuinely came to hate every scene with Chani in it in part 2.
I’m pretty happy with the visuals, the world and the performances. I’m sure it’ll be fine. I can live with thematic departures. At least the cannon was mostly completed - Looking at you Mr RR Martin.
Democrats destroy, ☢️, every single thing they touch.
As Dune progresses, I see Paul becoming ever more the reluctant hero, doing what he must but trapped within it. And the three women - Alia, Chani and Irulan - all join him in his fate.
Dune Messiah is Paul trying - and mostly failing - to process his sense of guilt for what has been done from his actions and in his name. And in some sense abandons his friends and loved ones in the process.
This is in contrast to Leto and his sister, who embrace fate rather than trying to circumvent it. Like his father, Leto does not let power go to his head. Unlike his father, he lets it into his heart and both he and the universe are better for it.
I don't mind them taking creative liberties with the original story, as long as it results in a good film. Humans are allowed to rewrite & adapt stories. That's what keeps it interesting. I thought the first two films were OK-good, not great, but not bad either, so maybe them deviating from the novel(s) on the third one could be a good sign.
You know they are going to fuck it up by making it some romantic tragedy or girlboss slop.
I’m not inclined to pay to see this 3rd installation. The previews just don’t seem interesting.
This isn't tinkering with plotlines or characters.
It's rewriting the whole ethos/message of the book.
It might as well be called Nude, or any other title not involving Dune.
This should have been a TV series. Dune part 1 was a painful watch. The sci-fi channel version achieved more despite its constraints.
This is a retarded choice if they want to keep making money off the series. The characters later in the series are absolutely defined by what happened to the family. Also, who wants to watch another lame divorce trope movie? I could see why they might make Chani more of a main character while working in the political scene - the stupid way would be to make her like the Lannister woman from GoT, but I could easily see them doing it.
Anyways, go woke go broke.
So instead of telling Herbets story the Director gives us a narcissistic meditation on his own divorce. I saw the other two. But I am not even tempted.
Pretty obvious they had to give her more agency to conform to rules against 'passive women' these days.
I wasn't expecting an un-woke Dune, but if it had been made after the Democrats retook power if would have been even worse. It's only downhill from here!