Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Nick Borodinov's avatar

Why can’t they simply make they own story from scratch, instead of telling us “here is Dune, but it’s not a real Dune”?

Some Asshole on the Internet's avatar

Very few good creative works can be directly transferred from one media to another without transforming it to some degree - and a great deal of license should be extended to those who adapt such works.

That said, there’s a huge difference between creative license and subversion.

Take just about any film/series adaptation of Le Comte de Monte-Cristo - acting, direction, and production value are at a level deserving of Dumas (the same cannot be said for Three Musketeers adaptations). It’s a long book, and abridging the story by combining/omitting characters or simplifying the plot is likely necessary to keep the attention of a modern audience.

Still, every single adaptation I’ve ever seen loses me at the very end, when it either reunites Mercedes and Dantès or has Haydée actually fall in love with Albert.

They’ve never left me feeling anything but betrayed by the time the credits roll.

20 more comments...

Ready for more?