9 Comments
User's avatar
J.R. Logan's avatar

We write for a reason. Lovecraft. Hemingway. Howard. Etc. Butcher is in good company if he can get help

Jason the Gentleman's avatar

Have been enjoying these books for years, you nailed it at the end, hopefully he does turn to Christ. Prayer said for him.

J. M. Cooper's avatar

Thanks for the article, Jon. Nobody else on my feed is covering this. Huge fan of the Dresden Files, here, and I echo that young man in saying that Jim Butcher's work pulled me through some rough times.

I hesitate to bring this up, but are you familiar with Alexander Dugin's Noomakhia theory? It might explain some of what Jim is going through. Basically, Dugin splits the human psyche into three faces: light (represented by Apollo), dark (Dionysus), and black (Cybele). Individuals and societies tend to cycle through phases of each.

Dresden is a Dionysian figure in much of the series—an irreverent but ultimately righteous hero. As of the book you cite, however, the series takes a distinctly Cybelean turn (readers of the series, once they look up Dugin's Noomakhia, will know what I mean).

Forgive my analytical babble; I don't mean to be callous. What I'm saying is that the same genius that gave us the Dresden Files has also plugged Jim into the zeitgeist of our society, which turned 100% Cybelean in the late 2000s/early 2010s—around the time he wrote Changes. For reference, the last time our society went through a Cybelean phase, we literally called it The Great Depression. The current Cybelean phase is a different beast, but still. Can't feel good to be plugged into that.

The good news here is that the Cybelean swamp always gives way to the next Apollonian rise. You'll get through this, Jim! We gotchu!

Terrie's avatar

I wish Butcher would join Substack

Flecktarn's avatar

I had no idea what Jim is dealing with. I can Imagine since I recently read a new book that calls attention to the male mental health taboos and the unnecessary struggles men go through because of them.

It is called "Cabinet of Confessions" by A.N. Archy

Aniela Connelly's avatar

I am so sorry to hear this about Jim Butcher. I have read through all his books twice and had wondered if there were personal issues hindering him from finishing the series. I always recommend his books to people who want something good to read. Writing is exhausting. G. K. Chesterton, extremely prolific writer that he was, broke down with mental exhaustion and was bedridden for about 6 months, as I recall, and unable even to talk. He eventually recovered, but such intense mental activity with pressure from deadlines and the need to make a living can be devastating.

I would like to write to Jim and tell him how much his books have meant to me, but I don't really know how to get in touch with him. Can one write to the publisher and trust that the letter or email will be forwarded?

Thanks for giving this update on him.