4 Comments
User's avatar
twb's avatar

Just good old-fashioned witch-hunting mentality. The accusation is the verdict, there is no way to prove your innocence. And that doesn't even address the question of why a method matters so much more than the quality of the product.

Matthew Husar's avatar

Because it's not about the quality of the product, but rather the shibboleths of the 'good people.' The anointed among the priestly class of leftists have decreed AI is anathema, while simultaneously earmarking an errata-free printing as evidence of AI use.

'Quality' is thus excluded from Chaosium's fold. Damn shame, since I love Lovecraftian influences in my fantasy, sci-fi, and RPGs. Not being willing to pay money to people who express hate for me does keep my wallet that much fuller, though.

Caffeinated Thomist's avatar

So we're banning autocorrect, spell checkers, and heck, why not grammarly? I wonder what the logical conclusion of this purity spiral will be?

Joseph L. Wiess's avatar

The tell list reads like a profile of a careful human writer. It includes “Absolutely perfect grammar and spelling, zero typos,” uniform formatting with many lists and tables, a breathless present-tense style, and “If not this, then that” syntax. The post also says “Em dashes, it’s always the em dashes.” Tabletop Sentinel reports Chaosium says none of these signs proves AI use alone. One sign is more concrete: O’Brien described a new author who publishes one or more scenarios a day, a pace that deserves scrutiny.

So, being able to spell a word correctly, using perfect grammar, and knowing how to use punctuation is now considered a sign of AI? My Middle-High school teachers would be very disappointed in that, considering that they drilled us with spelling bees, taught us the rules of grammar, and the use of punctuation, including Em and EN dashes.

The If/then statements sort of make sense, considering that they are a part of computer programming. If Lastname = Renard, then print "Coverletter" and $Pricelist.

But then, I'm more worried about GIGO than how the AI is used, because the intelligence is only as good as the input.